How is Insurance Priced?

Policyholders are always curious about how their rates are set. It’s especially confusing when the rates change, and they can’t make sense of why, let alone how. The reality is that insurance pricing has evolved into a sophisticated, complex statistical solution, making it harder to identify how premiums are determined. Simply put, understanding how insurance is priced can feel like trying to decode a complex formula. That’s because it is. In fact, many actuaries or product managers may even refer to it as a “black box.”
Insurance carriers don’t want the policyholder or even their insurance agents to feel like premium calculation is a black box, but the nature of assessing risk has evolved so far, that it’s hard to avoid these complexities. Especially if they’re going to compete in an ever-changing marketplace.
Nonetheless, for consumers, premiums appear to increase without rhyme or reason, even when they haven’t filed a claim. Let’s look at how insurance is priced, understanding it’s built on actuarial and statistical sciences that are attempting to determine a model for analyzing risk and predicting future costs.
Where does the pricing process start?
Insurance pricing is predicated on a combination of actuarial and statistical analysis. This analysis allows the insurance carrier to understand what changes should be made to maintain profitability, adjust to market conditions, exploit competitive advantage, or maintain the status quo. Overall, this is a very complex, ongoing analysis performed by fellows of the Actuarial Society (FCAS). Fortunately for our interests, we won’t need to have a degree in the actuarial sciences to understand the basics.
The fundamentals of insurance pricing
While we won’t need advanced math degrees or an FCAS to understand the basics, we will need to know a few things to get the picture:
Loss Development: Insurance companies look at past claims to predict future costs. This analysis allows the insurance company to understand how much claims will cost in the future, and how much money to reserve when a claim is opened. Because some claims take years to settle, insurers adjust their estimates over time to ensure they have enough money set aside, or reserved, to pay for them.
Claims Trends: Insurers track whether claims are becoming more frequent or expensive. If accidents, lawsuits, or repair costs are rising, premiums may need to be adjusted to cover the changes in these costs.
Premium Trends: Just as claims can change, so can the amount of money insurers collect in premiums. If fewer people are buying policies or discounts become more common, insurers may need to adjust pricing to maintain financial stability.
Loss Adjustment Expenses: Beyond paying claims, insurers also cover costs to investigate and process them. These expenses, like legal fees or claims adjuster salaries, are factored into the price of your insurance.
Operating Expenses: Running an insurance company involves costs like marketing, customer service, and technology. These business expenses are included in pricing to ensure the company can function effectively.
Profit Load: Insurance companies, like any business, need to make a reasonable profit to remain financially stable and continue offering coverage. A portion of premiums is set aside to ensure long-term sustainability.
The loss cost indication and base rates
When all analysis is completed, the results from these analyses become the component parts of the rate level indication. The indication takes the historical data, adjusts premiums to reflect the current rate level, draws in the historic losses, and applies an adjustment for adverse or favorable claims loss development as well as for claims trends. They then account for their expenses, and budgetary profit loads (between 4 – 9%), and determine the amount of rate they’ll need to remain profitable.
The indication can be a positive or a negative value. When the value is positive, the base rate needs to be increased, when it’s negative, the base rate can be lowered.
The classification plan
At its core, insurance pricing revolves around assessing risk. Insurers analyze the likelihood of a claim being made and how much it will cost to resolve. While the indication can tell them how much to change rates to achieve target profitability, targeting risk is the function of the classification factors. The classification plan allows insurers to spread the premium paid by policyholders in proportion to the assumed risk. Class factors are individual rating characteristics that allow the insurance carrier to target premiums where there is a higher likelihood of risk.
What are the class factors?
The classification plan can be different from company to company, and it’s always different from product to product. For example, in auto insurance, class factors might consider vehicle attributes like your vehicle’s make and model or the garaging address. It may also consider individual factors such as your driving record, age, gender, or marital status. Alternatively, homeowners’ insurance, factors may be things like your home’s construction materials, the age of the roof or construction, and proximity to natural catastrophes like floods or wildfires. The aim is to balance premiums so they’re fair to you while ensuring the insurer can cover claims and remain profitable.
How Do They Set the Class Factors?
The methods used to price different types of insurance have evolved significantly over time. Historically, insurers relied on univariate pricing models, such as pure premium or loss ratio methods, which examined individual risk factors in isolation. These models, while effective for their time, often oversimplified the complexities of risk.
Today, modern multivariate pricing models allow insurers to consider multiple factors simultaneously, leading to more accurate and equitable pricing. These advanced techniques leverage vast amounts of data and sophisticated algorithms to account for the interplay between various risk factors. The benefits of these modern models include improved risk prediction, more personalized pricing, and better management of overall portfolio profitability.
Different lines of insurance use distinct class parameters, reflecting the unique risks associated with each type of coverage:
- Auto Insurance: Factors include driving history, vehicle type, insurance scoring, underwriting tiering, and whether you’ve maintained continuous prior insurance coverage.
- Homeowners’ Insurance: Considers location, construction materials, proximity to fire stations, and weather-related risks.
- Life and Health Insurance: Relies on age, health status, lifestyle choices, and family medical history.
These differences reflect the unique risks and costs associated with each type of insurance, but the underlying principles remain consistent.
Why Do Rates Change?
Insurance rates are dynamic, responding to individual carrier changes and broader market or economic trends. Even if nothing changed and you didn’t a claim, your premium could increase due to:
- Market Factors: Inflation, rising repair costs, or more frequent natural disasters can drive up overall costs.
- Personal Factors: Changes in your risk profile, such as adding a teenage driver to your auto policy, remodeling your home, or getting a year older.
Sometimes rates change because the insurance company made changes to respond to change, and sometimes you premium change be you or the things your insure changed.
Each Policy Term Stands On It’s Own
Something insurance agents hear all the time, “I’ve never filed a claim, but my premium keeps going up. Why?” Premium changes can be confusing. It’s confusing because we don’t always consider insurance companies, like all other businesses, pay their taxes and report profitability to shareholders annually. When you purchase a policy, your premium reflects the insurer’s projection of potential claims and costs for that specific year, not the lifetime of your policy. Think of it like a subscription that resets annually based on new data.
This annual approach is tied to what’s known as the combined operating ratio, which is a high-level assessment of the insurance carrier’s profitability. It brings together the losses, general expenses, and profit provision to provide the insurer if they made money, or didn’t. While the loss ratio—the percentage of premiums collected that go toward paying claims—is a significant component, the combined operating ratio gives a more comprehensive view by factoring in operational costs and profit margins. A profitable year for an insurer occurs when the combined operating ratio is below 100%, meaning they’ve collected more in premiums than the total cost of claims and expenses. Conversely, unexpected events like natural disasters can lead to unprofitable years, requiring adjustments in future pricing trends.
California’s Unique Auto Insurance Pricing
California stands out due to Proposition 103, a law requiring insurers to base auto insurance premiums primarily on three factors: driving safety record, annual mileage, and years of driving experience. Other considerations, like ZIP codes or credit scores, cannot weigh as heavily as they do in most other states. This prescribed sequential analysis and weighting process aims to ensure fair pricing but comes with limitations.
The sequential method used in California, while consumer-friendly, is considered outdated compared to modern multivariate models. Multivariate approaches, like generalized linear models (GLMs), allow insurers in most other states to assess multiple factors simultaneously and account for their interactions. This results in more accurate risk assessments and pricing. By contrast, California’s prescribed method can oversimplify risks, potentially leading to inefficiencies and less precise rate setting for drivers. As the insurance industry continues to evolve, the differences in pricing methodologies highlight the challenges of balancing regulatory standards with technological advancements.
Making Sense of Your Premiums
While insurance pricing may feel opaque, it’s rooted in fairness and careful analysis. Understanding the factors that influence your premiums can help you make informed decisions. For instance:
- Reduce Risk: Safe driving, home improvements, or healthy lifestyle changes can lower your premiums.
- Shop Around: Comparing quotes ensures you’re getting competitive rates.
- Leverage Discounts: Many insurers offer savings for bundling policies or maintaining coverage with them over time.
The Bottom Line
Insurance is priced to manage risk, maintain fairness, and ensure the industry’s financial health. By understanding the process, you’ll not only demystify your premiums but also gain insights into how you can take control of your insurance costs. Whether you’re insuring your car, home, or life, knowing what goes into the price can help you make smarter choices and find the coverage that fits your needs.

Compare Business Quotes
Looking for business insurance? Click “Start a Quote” to compare Business Owner’s Policy and Worker’s Compensation rates. Ready to purchase? Choose “Quote & Buy Online” to buy directly online.
Rather speak with an insurance agent?
1-877-334-7646