Skip to main content

Should I Choose an Independent or a Captive Insurance Agent?

Captive Insurance Agent

Today’s consumers have more ways than ever to purchase an insurance policy, thanks to digital and mobile advancements. However, despite these technological innovations, there are still only two primary channels for buying insurance: directly from an insurance company or through an insurance agent. If you choose to work with an agent, should you opt for an independent or a captive insurance agent?

Let’s break down the differences between the two and explore the of working with an independent insurance agent or a captive agent.

What is a captive insurance agent?

A captive insurance agent represents only one insurance company or a group of affiliated companies. Their exclusivity means they can only offer policies from their specific insurer or carrier group, which can limit their ability to provide a broad range of coverage options or products.

Most captive agents sell both personal and business insurance, but their policies must come from their host insurance carrier or group.

In many cases, captive agents are either salaried employees or independent contractors working under an exclusive selling agreement. Consumers are most familiar with captive insurance agents from brands like State Farm and Farmers.

Benefits of a captive insurance agent

  • Product expertise: Since captive agents work exclusively with one insurance provider, they develop deep knowledge of their policies, coverage options, and benefits. This expertise allows them to provide detailed information about the policies they sell.

  • Brand recognition: Captive insurers invest heavily in direct advertising, increasing brand awareness. As a result, consumers are often more familiar with captive insurance carriers than independent agency brands.

  • Loyalty to their company: Captive agents have a vested interest in promoting their carrier’s products and making them work for clients. However, their compensation and bonuses are tied to the company, which may influence their recommendations.

What is an independent insurance agent?

Most aren’t even aware that there are differences in insurance agents, and may be asking, what is an independent insurance agent? Independent agents are insurance agents who are not tied to any single insurance company. They have the freedom to offer policies from multiple insurers, giving them the ability to provide more customized coverage options tailored to a client’s specific needs. Independent agents typically earn commissions based on the policies they sell.

Benefits of an independent insurance agent

  • Choice: Independent agents have access to policies from multiple carriers, allowing them to compare coverage options and pricing to find the best fit for their clients.

  • Unbiased recommendations: Since they are not bound to one insurer, independent agents can provide objective advice and recommend policies based solely on the client’s needs.

  • Cost savings: By comparing multiple insurers, independent agents can often find better rates and discounts, helping clients save money on their insurance.

Comparing insurance companies

Independent agents frequently specialize in different insurance types, such as professional liability, life insurance, or business coverage. Others may focus on nonstandard auto insurance for hard-to-place drivers.

Below is a comparison of some well-known captive and independent insurance companies:

Captive CompaniesIndependent CompaniesWork with Both
State FarmSafecoNationwide
FarmersTravelersAllstate
American FamilyLiberty Mutual
The Hartford
Progressive
Chubb

Some insurance companies that distribute through independent agents, like Travelers and The Hartford, have been in business for over a century, demonstrating their reliability and strength. To evaluate an insurer’s financial health, check their AM Best ratings or JD Power rankings.

Choosing the right insurance agent

Your choice of insurance agent should be based on your specific needs, comfort level, and the agent’s ability to provide transparent and comprehensive coverage recommendations.

Make sure your agent answers your questions thoroughly and helps you understand your policy options. Avoid agents who downplay essential coverages just to offer a lower price.

The bottom line

The best insurance agent is the one who prioritizes YOUR interests, provides expert guidance, and makes insurance shopping easy. If you’re looking for personalized coverage options, contact us, or start your quote online today.

Compare Quotes Online

Compare Home Insurance Quotes

Want to know if you can save on home or auto insurance? See for yourself. Start a quote today.

Give us a Ring

1-877-334-7646

Call today and speak with a professional insurance agent.

Follow us!

Share via
Copy link